You’ve got your funnel mapped out, you’ve created your asset, and you’ve set the plan in motion. But as you sit behind your screen watching ads You’ve got your funnel mapped out, you’ve created the assets, and you’ve officially entered the “watch and wait” stage—but as you sit behind your screen watching ads go live and emails deploy, you can’t help but wonder: “How do I know if it’s actually working?”

Spoiler: If you’ve ever felt that, you’re not alone. Funnels are brilliant, but they’re not always instant. The good news? Testing and optimizing doesn’t have to feel like a Rubik’s cube.

Step One: What Metrics Actually Matter

Before you tweak, panic, or throw the whole funnel away (don’t you dare), let’s focus on what to track. These are the core metrics you’ll use to read your funnel like a seasoned pro.

Ads

• Click-Through Rate (CTR)
  
• Cost Per Click (CPC)
  
• Opt-in Conversion Rate
  

Landing Page

• Page Views
  
• Opt-in Conversion Rate (Benchmark: 20–40%)
  
• Bounce Rate
  

Emails

• Open Rate (Benchmark: 30–40%)
  
• Click-Through Rate (Benchmark: 2–5%)
  
• Unsubscribe Rate (<1%)
  

Sales

• Webinar Show-Up Rate (30–50%)
  
• Sales Page Conversion Rate (1–5%)
  
• Funnel-Wide Conversion Rate (Total opt-ins to buyers: 1–5%)
  

Step Two: Decoding What Those Numbers Are Actually Telling You

• Low ad CTR = Your messaging or creative might not be landing.
  
• Low opt-in rate = Your landing page probably needs a stronger hook or simpler design.
  
• High email opens but low clicks = Your calls-to-action might need more spice.
  
• Low webinar show-up rate = Check your reminder sequence and urgency triggers.
  
• Low sales conversion = Your sales page or post-workshop follow-up might not be handling objections well.
  

Step Three: How Much Traffic is Enough to Test? (No Spiral Required)

You’ve probably heard rumors that you need thousands of leads to run valid tests. Here’s the reality for our industry:

• 30–50 people through the funnel is enough to catch obvious gaps (early-stage testing).
  
• 75–100 people can reveal patterns and directional insights.
  
• 100–200+ starts to give you clearer confidence, especially when testing one specific variable.
  

For most entrepreneurs creating their first evergreen funnel, use what you’ve got. Real-life patterns—even in small batches—are more valuable than you think.

Step Four: Reading and Reacting To Your Funnel Data

Scenario 1: Opt-in Conversion is Below 20%

Try this:

• Rewrite your headline to focus on the core desire or transformation.
  
• Swap your opt-in hook for something less “educational” and more “I need this yesterday.”
  
• Simplify visuals that might be overwhelming.
  

Scenario 2: Email Open Rate is <25%

Try this:

• Experiment with subject lines (curiosity, urgency, relevance).
  
• Space out your emails more if you’re overwhelming them.
  
• Clean your list to remove cold or unengaged subscribers.
  

Scenario 3: Webinar Show-Up Rate is <30%

Try this:

• Send a mix of emails and DMs for reminders.
  
• Emphasize urgency + benefits over just logistics.
  
• Consider offering a small incentive to live attendees.
  

Scenario 4: Sales Conversion is <1%

Try this:

• Are you REALLY selling, or just educating and hoping they connect the dots?
  
• Update your sales page to address common objections and buying hesitations.
  
• Add a conversion event or bonus that makes action feel irresistible.
  

Step Five: A/B Testing Without Making it a Whole Thing

You don’t need fancy data software and a seven-figure ad spend to A/B test.

If you have 50 people coming through:

• Test two versions of a subject line.
  
• Test two different bonus offers.
  
• Test two webinar reminder sequences.
  

You’ll get valuable directional insight, even if it’s not perfectly “statistical.”Golden Rule: Only change ONE thing at a time. Otherwise, you’ll have no clue what worked.

Key Insight: In Evergreen, It’s Never “Set It and Forget It”

Your evergreen funnel is meant to evolve, just like you. Your messaging, hooks, pacing, and even bonuses will shift as your audience matures and your offer evolves. The goal isn’t perfection—it’s sustainable improvement.

Free Resource Recommendation

Want more insights like these? Get weekly behind-the-scenes breakdowns of what’s working in the online space inside The Goods Newsletter.

Click here to subscribe →